Critical Thinking: What Strong Observation Evidence Can Look Like

Connect content, curriculum implementation, critical thinking, student learning, and positive environment to authentic student reasoning and evidence. For Critical Thinking, the strongest preparation question is not “Did I mention it?” but “What student evidence will make this part of Missouri Educator Evaluation observable?”

A classroom micro-scenario

Students must choose among competing strategies, justify the choice using evidence, and explain how the result would change under a new condition.

Teacher moves that fit this component

• protect the hard thinking for students
• ask for reasoning and transfer
• use scaffolds that support access without doing the thinking

Evidence students can produce

• students make and defend decisions
• multiple approaches are compared
• tasks require conceptual reasoning

What an administrator may be able to see

• students working with concepts, relationships, evidence, or transfer rather than only recall
• teacher prompts that require justification and connection
• accurate disciplinary language and representations

What students might be doing

• analyze a pattern or relationship
• justify a claim or solution with disciplinary evidence
• transfer a concept to a new context

What students might be saying

• “The relationship changes when…”
• “This evidence is stronger because…”
• “I can apply the same principle in a different situation by…”

Artifacts that can make evidence concrete

• concept map, model, proof, claim-evidence-reasoning, or analytical annotation
• disciplinary vocabulary used in context
• student comparison of methods or interpretations

Weak evidence vs. stronger evidence

Common missed opportunities

• Critical Thinking is named in the lesson plan but no student behavior demonstrates it.
• The teacher can explain the intent, but the observer would have to infer too much because the evidence remains hidden.
• Only one student produces the evidence, so it is difficult to judge how broadly learning is occurring.
• The teacher collects information but the next instructional move does not respond to it.

Planning questions for Critical Thinking

1. At what exact moment should Critical Thinking become visible?
2. What should students be doing differently because this component is strong?
3. What student language would tell me the intended thinking is actually happening?
4. What artifact, response, or behavior can provide evidence beyond my own explanation?
5. What will I change if the evidence is weaker or stronger than expected?

Related Missouri Educator Evaluation components